Hewitt recently discussed not seeing costar Sarah Michelle Gellar, Prinze's wife, in decades either — while also waving away feud rumors

Jennifer Love Hewitt is looking back on the I Know What You Did Last Summer premiere with pride. The actress, 46, told Us Weekly exclusively that she had some reservations about returning to the red carpet on July 18 for the film's opening night,

Freddie Prinze Jr. and Jennifer Love Hewitt survived the original “I Know What You Did Last Summer” — but they can’t escape from new fan theories. Twenty-eight years after the 1997 slasher hit theaters,